The Great Debaters
It is probably not a
coincidence that the poster for Denzel Washington's latest film, The
Great Debaters -- about a teacher who brings out the best in his poor
small-town students -- seems to be modeled simply after classic Sidney Poitier one sheets
like Blackboard Jungle, In the Heat of the Night or To Sir, With Love.
Though the film actually
takes place decades before the Poitier classics were made, it is reminiscent
of them in tone and content. This is an old-fashioned
tale of smart people overcoming overwhelming odds and unfair prejudices to
fly higher than they even imagined that they could reach. And it is
mostly true.
Of course, things are kind
of stacked in the Wiley College debate team's favor. The Great Debaters does take a
somewhat rose-colored glasses look at this true story. Not saying that
the story is not worthy or that what the individuals achieved was not great.
However, the story is given a Hollywood gloss to assure that we embrace
them.
The Great Debaters
tells the story of the Wiley College debate team in 1935. In
the midst of the Jim Crow south, a debate team made up of African Americans
was able - through eloquence and intelligence - to make such an academic
impression that they finally became the first college to break the color
barrier.
However, the real Wiley
College debate team never went to Harvard - which is only the entire thrust of the movie.
In real life they went to the University of Southern California (USC) - a nice, important, mainstream university,
certainly, but not quite the hallowed halls of academia.
Also, the script assures that the
Wiley debate team conveniently always gets to argue
the politically and morally correct point-of-view on all subjects, never once being forced
into the role of devil's advocate -- like all of their opponents are
required to throughout the storyline.
And finally, when they do
arrive at Harvard, they are forced to use their own words and thoughts, not
just the script of their Professor -- social advocate and future poet Melvin
Tolson (played with charming academic stiffness by Denzel Washington.).
The students complain when
they are forced to come up with their own arguments - however it seems
perfectly reasonable to me that Harvard insists on this. In fact, it
was disappointing to me that they did not do it the whole time. I'm an
outsider to the debating world, so maybe that is how it is done, it just
seemed wrong somehow.
Still, even if it is a
slightly white-washed version of the truth, The Great Debaters is an
important story to tell and told with passion.
The acting - particularly
Forest Whitaker as a preacher father, Nate Parker as the handsome and suave
debater and Denzel Whitaker (who is not related to either Forest Whitaker or
Denzel Washington - but whose parents may have been fans) as the young, shy
prodigal student - shines through with fierce elegance.
The Great Debaters
takes many of the staples of the sports inspirational film (in fact Parker,
as good as he was, essentially played the same role in last year's swimming
movie Pride) and gives them an academic twist. This can only be
a good thing in a world which is getting increasingly dumbed down.
Jay S. Jacobs
Copyright ©2008 PopEntertainment.com. All rights reserved.
Posted: January 4, 2008.
